Chris, thank you for this wonderful and fascinating post. Big picture strategic engineering thinking runs in your veins!
Canada’s example played an important role for Australia by providing a non-Republican model for the Federation that was to be realised on 1 Jan 1901. This was first mentioned in a little known public speech at Ballarat in 1869, referencing the 1867 events in Canada. So important that we all know our history, both family and national.
Not to mention all those papists especially in Quebec, threatening your Homeland utopia eh?
Nobody from Canada is exporting a Hindu assault, exporting nothing on the level of US firearms and fascist interference in our affairs coming the other way.
Do us all a favour including your own countrymen. Stick to your own knitting and leave Canada the f alone.
And a ccp oupost and fentanyl port. When it comes to stuff like that idgaf about canadian sovereignty. And whenever theres lockdowns or major free speech shutdowns in the anglosphere i think america should invade or at least support a local insurgency.
Your FCC threatens late night comics it doesn’t like as your oligarchs buy up studios and broadcasters so they can pump divisive destruction into your sick MAGA gun culture through their energy-sucking, water-depleting data centres that they force down your throats.
You can try invading, but your ragtag little militia will be sent packing faster than Benedict Arnold was dispatched from Quebec, faster than your festering sore of an Oompa Loompa was driven to his knees in the Strait of Hormuz.
If America doesn’t succeed in driving the likes of you back into your hole where you belong, it’s done for.
Personally, I blame it all on the Brits front running us with the Quebec Act of 1774.
Otherwise, no one in North America would have ever put cucumbers on a ham sandwich and called the damn thing "Jambon-Beurre." It shouldn't be that hard to get a ham and American cheese sandwich in Montreal circa 2003 but forget it ever since the Quebec Act.
Personally, I like you just the way you are, separate.
Looneys
Tooneys
Can't pronounce anything ending in "out" properly
Timmy's
The birds on your prairies and that prairie sky....
Even the funny "Les bisons sont dangereux!" signs ... everything is endearing just the way it is.
OMB was never going to annex Canada (or Greenland). The trade war and the rhetoric are a mistake but your sovereignty is not in question.
Signed,
1/4 Canadian (grandma from Winnipeg...)
p.s. you Keefers sure do like to have your hands in things, huh?
The Canadian/American border is one of the few completely natural borders in the world. It follows the watersheds all across the continent. Not that there has to be a border but if you are going to have one, it's current location is exactly where to put it. There are a few dips and doodles of course but they were imposed on to the original vision.
One of the most notable was revision of the Fraser River watershed to replace the original Columbia River watershed removing what is now Washington state from the then British/Canadian view of the situation. The *little* dip was imposed by Teddy Roosevelt in his big stick mode.
An incisive and significant précis of the background to the current contentious situation. Incidentally, Keefer women played their part as well: George's first wife died from an infection caught while nursing wounded soldiers transferred to the Keefer home during the war of 1812
Canada inherited a lot from England, and not all of it served the country well. Because Canada didn’t have its own constitution for more than a century and simply followed British constitutional traditions, it never developed anything like the U.S. Commerce Clause formalized in 1787. That clause is what forces American states to allow free trade with each other. Canada never got that. Without it, provinces can obstruct one another and operate like mini‑countries inside the federation.
You can still see the consequences today. Eastern Canadians can’t easily use oil from the West because provincial rules and political resistance block pipelines. Quebec remains strongly protectionist and can stop anything that doesn’t benefit Quebec directly. And when the U.S. tries to negotiate trade agreements with Canada, many of the sticking points — dairy, alcohol, construction standards, trucking rules come down to provincial barriers as much as, or more than, federal ones. Quebec is the most protectionist province, and its internal rules give it enough leverage to effectively block national trade deals.
Canada’s development is fundamentally different from that of the United States, and a large part of that comes from the institutional and cultural backgrounds of the early settlers. Canada was essentially granted status by the UK rather than fighting for sovereignty. It was shaped first by French Catholic settlement and later by British Loyalists who moved north after the American Revolution. These communities lived within centralized imperial and clerical structures, which produced a political culture comfortable with continuity and hierarchy.
Had the United States not rebelled, things likely would have unfolded very differently. Britain learned from the mistakes it made with the Thirteen Colonies. Instead of imposing heavy‑handed control again, it treated Canada far better — granting autonomy gradually, allowing local governance to develop, and avoiding the kind of confrontation that had triggered revolution in the south. Canada became a Dominion through negotiation and inheritance, not rupture.
Canada didn’t win independence through conflict; it evolved into it. For more than a century it operated under British constitutional traditions, and it didn’t receive full constitutional control until 1982. Older Canadians still remember singing God Save the Queen because Canada remained closely tied to Britain for most of its history.
In short, Canada’s national identity was shaped by continuity with British authority, while the United States was shaped by a break from it. Britain’s experience with the American Revolution directly influenced how Canada was governed — and Canada benefited from that lesson.
I enjoyed this little story and education, thank you. I’ve spent a lot of time in Canada 🇨🇦, it used to be such an easy transaction to come and go. Somehow, 9/11 terrorist attacks made the process much harder. Growing up close to Sault St. Marie Canada we crossed over to get snowmobile parts, and went up canoeing and fishing regularly. After I got older and changed careers I made several visits to the prairies. My mom and dad even took us to Regina when we were kids to see the house my Grandpa grew up in. Oh how I miss the days when we were the best of neighbors and both countries functioned with common sense and generally the citizens were in agreement on most policies. Somewhere wokeness and mass immigration came along and a lot has changed. I did have one terrible experience with mosquitos and the meanest black flies ever on a canoe trip, so bad we slept in head nets and sealed ourselves in our sleeping bags. Fair trade for a 10 day trip of a lifetime 🦟🪰🤠🍁🫎🐟🦌
I'm about 2/3 of the way through the excellent book Crucible of War by Fred Anderson. His argues that the French and Indian war did more to shape the future of the colonies and Canada then the Revolutionary War. It Expelled the French of course and gave the British sovereignty over large areas of loosely governed land. Meanwhile the colonists began to band together and regard the British as outsiders trying to tell him what to do. The New England colonies had contributed very substantial resources in men and material to fight the war and now they were being denied the spoils. They all expected that the Indians would lose the Ohio country and were shocked when the British attempted to prevent migration.
Inhabitants of Canada felt none of this resentment and really didn't care that the British will now in charge instead of the French king, due to, as you say, the Quebec act.
I recently read a wonderful (but not particularly popular) book on the loyalist Americans who fled at the end of the American Revolution. Many were re-settled in Nova Scotia and in New Brunswick, a province that was created for them.
The fact that Canada became a federal, parliamentary democracy also had a lot to do with America’s 200 plus year old decision not to envelope Canada. From a realist viewpoint it definitely could/should have done so by now. The liberal peace theory says otherwise. Also, despite the east-west connection you highlight with the railroad there is enough economic flow from Canada to the US to assuage the US. For instance, most of Canada’s hydrocarbons still go to US refineries as you point out.
Stanley Lipset’s book “Continental Divide” does a very good job of explaining why the two so similarly cultural peoples have developed differences that keep them politically separate.
As an aside, the US’s and Canada’s decision to build railroads and then roads across their continents and America’s ability to finish the Panama Canal made any development of the famed Northest passage much more unlikely.
I didnt have time/word count to get into John A MacDonald's National Policy but that was key aswell. The Northwest passage is a garbage waterway.. nothing like the Northern Sea Route which connects Asia to Europe 12 days faster and avoids Mallaca and Red Sea Houthi's. ALso fascinating from a nuclear perspective if you've seen my work on that.
The NSR isn’t much better as a waterway, but when a country has few warm water ports, like Russia, and other choke points are contested like Suez, the Dardanelles, the SOH, the Baltic Sea and Malacca, it certainly becomes more valuable. This isn’t the first time Russia has learned this lesson and that is why it is has spilt so much blood and treasure into making the NSR a viable line of communication. The US and Canada are truly fortuitous in their geography which luckily makes it less necessary for the John Franklins of the world to forge their way through the NW Passage.
When the US purchased Alaska, shortly after the Civil War militarization Chris mentions, there was a fairly large consensus in the US that Canada would eventually and willingly join the US. The US has not seriously threatened Canada militarily since then and debatably since the War of 1812 that Chris also mentions. 200 plus years is a very long time for neighbors with such relative material imbalances to have such peaceful relations. It is a testament to the liberal peace theory in my opinion.
"decision" you say. It's not like Americans didn't try so really a forced decision. Nowadays it seems America is tearing itself asunder. Perhaps some parts might want to join the Great White North. Perhaps a trade for Alberta? ;)
To better understand the Cowboy & Oilman Conservative Alberta Independence from Canada Referendum Movement, visit the Alberta Prosperity Project and Stay Free Alberta websites!
Chris, thank you for this wonderful and fascinating post. Big picture strategic engineering thinking runs in your veins!
Canada’s example played an important role for Australia by providing a non-Republican model for the Federation that was to be realised on 1 Jan 1901. This was first mentioned in a little known public speech at Ballarat in 1869, referencing the 1867 events in Canada. So important that we all know our history, both family and national.
Best, Stephen
I come by my nationalism and CANDU advocacy epigenitically.
Why does Canada exist?
Apparently it exists as a Hindu staging ground for Indias assault on America.
Not to mention all those papists especially in Quebec, threatening your Homeland utopia eh?
Nobody from Canada is exporting a Hindu assault, exporting nothing on the level of US firearms and fascist interference in our affairs coming the other way.
Do us all a favour including your own countrymen. Stick to your own knitting and leave Canada the f alone.
And a ccp oupost and fentanyl port. When it comes to stuff like that idgaf about canadian sovereignty. And whenever theres lockdowns or major free speech shutdowns in the anglosphere i think america should invade or at least support a local insurgency.
Your FCC threatens late night comics it doesn’t like as your oligarchs buy up studios and broadcasters so they can pump divisive destruction into your sick MAGA gun culture through their energy-sucking, water-depleting data centres that they force down your throats.
You can try invading, but your ragtag little militia will be sent packing faster than Benedict Arnold was dispatched from Quebec, faster than your festering sore of an Oompa Loompa was driven to his knees in the Strait of Hormuz.
If America doesn’t succeed in driving the likes of you back into your hole where you belong, it’s done for.
Leave Canada the f alone.
Personally, I blame it all on the Brits front running us with the Quebec Act of 1774.
Otherwise, no one in North America would have ever put cucumbers on a ham sandwich and called the damn thing "Jambon-Beurre." It shouldn't be that hard to get a ham and American cheese sandwich in Montreal circa 2003 but forget it ever since the Quebec Act.
Personally, I like you just the way you are, separate.
Looneys
Tooneys
Can't pronounce anything ending in "out" properly
Timmy's
The birds on your prairies and that prairie sky....
Even the funny "Les bisons sont dangereux!" signs ... everything is endearing just the way it is.
OMB was never going to annex Canada (or Greenland). The trade war and the rhetoric are a mistake but your sovereignty is not in question.
Signed,
1/4 Canadian (grandma from Winnipeg...)
p.s. you Keefers sure do like to have your hands in things, huh?
😉
The Canadian/American border is one of the few completely natural borders in the world. It follows the watersheds all across the continent. Not that there has to be a border but if you are going to have one, it's current location is exactly where to put it. There are a few dips and doodles of course but they were imposed on to the original vision.
One of the most notable was revision of the Fraser River watershed to replace the original Columbia River watershed removing what is now Washington state from the then British/Canadian view of the situation. The *little* dip was imposed by Teddy Roosevelt in his big stick mode.
Good point, but watersheds in the praerie areas do not represent formidable natural boundaries. Love the detail on Teddy's big stick though!
Ahh but they do when they are the only means of transportation such as when the borders were being worked out.
An incisive and significant précis of the background to the current contentious situation. Incidentally, Keefer women played their part as well: George's first wife died from an infection caught while nursing wounded soldiers transferred to the Keefer home during the war of 1812
Canada inherited a lot from England, and not all of it served the country well. Because Canada didn’t have its own constitution for more than a century and simply followed British constitutional traditions, it never developed anything like the U.S. Commerce Clause formalized in 1787. That clause is what forces American states to allow free trade with each other. Canada never got that. Without it, provinces can obstruct one another and operate like mini‑countries inside the federation.
You can still see the consequences today. Eastern Canadians can’t easily use oil from the West because provincial rules and political resistance block pipelines. Quebec remains strongly protectionist and can stop anything that doesn’t benefit Quebec directly. And when the U.S. tries to negotiate trade agreements with Canada, many of the sticking points — dairy, alcohol, construction standards, trucking rules come down to provincial barriers as much as, or more than, federal ones. Quebec is the most protectionist province, and its internal rules give it enough leverage to effectively block national trade deals.
A very small price to pay, since without Quebec, Canada would NOT exist.
Canada’s development is fundamentally different from that of the United States, and a large part of that comes from the institutional and cultural backgrounds of the early settlers. Canada was essentially granted status by the UK rather than fighting for sovereignty. It was shaped first by French Catholic settlement and later by British Loyalists who moved north after the American Revolution. These communities lived within centralized imperial and clerical structures, which produced a political culture comfortable with continuity and hierarchy.
Had the United States not rebelled, things likely would have unfolded very differently. Britain learned from the mistakes it made with the Thirteen Colonies. Instead of imposing heavy‑handed control again, it treated Canada far better — granting autonomy gradually, allowing local governance to develop, and avoiding the kind of confrontation that had triggered revolution in the south. Canada became a Dominion through negotiation and inheritance, not rupture.
Canada didn’t win independence through conflict; it evolved into it. For more than a century it operated under British constitutional traditions, and it didn’t receive full constitutional control until 1982. Older Canadians still remember singing God Save the Queen because Canada remained closely tied to Britain for most of its history.
In short, Canada’s national identity was shaped by continuity with British authority, while the United States was shaped by a break from it. Britain’s experience with the American Revolution directly influenced how Canada was governed — and Canada benefited from that lesson.
I enjoyed this little story and education, thank you. I’ve spent a lot of time in Canada 🇨🇦, it used to be such an easy transaction to come and go. Somehow, 9/11 terrorist attacks made the process much harder. Growing up close to Sault St. Marie Canada we crossed over to get snowmobile parts, and went up canoeing and fishing regularly. After I got older and changed careers I made several visits to the prairies. My mom and dad even took us to Regina when we were kids to see the house my Grandpa grew up in. Oh how I miss the days when we were the best of neighbors and both countries functioned with common sense and generally the citizens were in agreement on most policies. Somewhere wokeness and mass immigration came along and a lot has changed. I did have one terrible experience with mosquitos and the meanest black flies ever on a canoe trip, so bad we slept in head nets and sealed ourselves in our sleeping bags. Fair trade for a 10 day trip of a lifetime 🦟🪰🤠🍁🫎🐟🦌
I'm about 2/3 of the way through the excellent book Crucible of War by Fred Anderson. His argues that the French and Indian war did more to shape the future of the colonies and Canada then the Revolutionary War. It Expelled the French of course and gave the British sovereignty over large areas of loosely governed land. Meanwhile the colonists began to band together and regard the British as outsiders trying to tell him what to do. The New England colonies had contributed very substantial resources in men and material to fight the war and now they were being denied the spoils. They all expected that the Indians would lose the Ohio country and were shocked when the British attempted to prevent migration.
Inhabitants of Canada felt none of this resentment and really didn't care that the British will now in charge instead of the French king, due to, as you say, the Quebec act.
Chris, I enjoyed your post.
I recently read a wonderful (but not particularly popular) book on the loyalist Americans who fled at the end of the American Revolution. Many were re-settled in Nova Scotia and in New Brunswick, a province that was created for them.
That influx helped shape Canada.
https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/86852/libertys-exiles-by-maya-jasanoff/
Pierre Burton’s “Flames across the border” people’s history format is SUCH a good read on 1812 War
This is a great bit of history, and it's fascinating that your ancestors played such prominent roles in the early years of a young Canada.
You inherited good genes, Chris.
why does Canada exist in 2026
Thanks for the color.
The fact that Canada became a federal, parliamentary democracy also had a lot to do with America’s 200 plus year old decision not to envelope Canada. From a realist viewpoint it definitely could/should have done so by now. The liberal peace theory says otherwise. Also, despite the east-west connection you highlight with the railroad there is enough economic flow from Canada to the US to assuage the US. For instance, most of Canada’s hydrocarbons still go to US refineries as you point out.
Stanley Lipset’s book “Continental Divide” does a very good job of explaining why the two so similarly cultural peoples have developed differences that keep them politically separate.
As an aside, the US’s and Canada’s decision to build railroads and then roads across their continents and America’s ability to finish the Panama Canal made any development of the famed Northest passage much more unlikely.
I didnt have time/word count to get into John A MacDonald's National Policy but that was key aswell. The Northwest passage is a garbage waterway.. nothing like the Northern Sea Route which connects Asia to Europe 12 days faster and avoids Mallaca and Red Sea Houthi's. ALso fascinating from a nuclear perspective if you've seen my work on that.
The NSR isn’t much better as a waterway, but when a country has few warm water ports, like Russia, and other choke points are contested like Suez, the Dardanelles, the SOH, the Baltic Sea and Malacca, it certainly becomes more valuable. This isn’t the first time Russia has learned this lesson and that is why it is has spilt so much blood and treasure into making the NSR a viable line of communication. The US and Canada are truly fortuitous in their geography which luckily makes it less necessary for the John Franklins of the world to forge their way through the NW Passage.
When the US purchased Alaska, shortly after the Civil War militarization Chris mentions, there was a fairly large consensus in the US that Canada would eventually and willingly join the US. The US has not seriously threatened Canada militarily since then and debatably since the War of 1812 that Chris also mentions. 200 plus years is a very long time for neighbors with such relative material imbalances to have such peaceful relations. It is a testament to the liberal peace theory in my opinion.
"decision" you say. It's not like Americans didn't try so really a forced decision. Nowadays it seems America is tearing itself asunder. Perhaps some parts might want to join the Great White North. Perhaps a trade for Alberta? ;)
As an Albertan, I say no.
Part of the answer to why Canada exists is that the Canadian population remain faithful to the crown at a critical time. The US colonies did not.
True, those colonies had legitimate grievances.
To better understand the Cowboy & Oilman Conservative Alberta Independence from Canada Referendum Movement, visit the Alberta Prosperity Project and Stay Free Alberta websites!
Conservative Alberta is voting for independence from Woke-Communist "Liberal" Canada on October 19th! 🇨🇦🗳
President Trump will recognize the independence of Cowboy Conservative Oil-Rich Alberta,and maybe offer 51st Statehood! 🇺🇲